Jan 27 2007
The technology “bath water”-Taking Risks
I have often wondered what would happen if my school stopped using filters. What would happened if edublogs, del.icio.us, and various other web 2.o standards were not blocked? What would happen if we taught students the educational value of cell phones and MySpace?
More often than not talk of MySpace, chatting/IMing and blogging are synonymous with social subversion. I was one of the proponents who openly believed that that blocking all this content was the proper way a school should deal with these concerns.
Reading Chris Lehman and Christopher Sessums today challenged me to think on how educational belief systems (mine included), need to change in regards to the use of technology. Since I began blogging I realize the misuse of technology is unavoidable, kids are kids. As Chris Lehman discusses when kids are empowered they, they use that power. Sometimes, especially in the instance that Chris was discussing; they will challenge authority and press buttons.
We had some students use the laptops and instant messaging in really inappropriate ways. It was upsetting teachers and students alike, and we saw a creeping loss of a sense of safety. So what did we do? We talked about it as a community on our moodle site. The student forums were suddenly filled with conversations about what was going on, what screen names to beware of, how to block someone in iChat, and (I’m not kidding) discussion by students about how poorly this reflected on our community.
Reading the above was truly inspiring and gives a beautiful mental image of the Science Leadership Academy and how the building runs. In this instance Chris was faced with the possibility of ceasing IMing completely, he chose however to continue the empowerment of his students and to elicit student response. In the end, the students were upset and did not support or encourage this behavior either. Chris could have thrown out the baby (a use of technology) with the bath water (poor behavior), but instead he chose to yet empower his students more.
The tactic of open discussion and using students to address the technology concerns of the school community is provides intrinsic motivation for appropriate behavior rather than just the traditional response of yanking the technology away. In all honesty I think we all know that when we yank it away, the kids show their ingenuity by circumventing nearly all those efforts and regaining access themselves .
“There is no panacea in education and every great idea has a dark side, so what are the worst consequences of your best ideas?” It’s important to do for two reasons — one because I think that many educational institutions become reactionary too often, throwing the baby out with the bathwater when an unforeseen consequence of a really good idea comes along.
Remember the saying “Fear is the path to dark side”? If we allow our fears of what could happen stop us from seizing the opportunities before us then we will never really grow.
The “baby” is the opportunity that comes from access to technology in schools. The bathwater is all the nasty little by-products of good ideas that always occur, because where there are humans learning there are mistakes. People (especially teens) push limitations and challenge authority. If we expect it, and deal with it as a part of the learning process (like Chris Lehman) we stand the chance of learning in the most profound lessons, the ones we learn through adversity.
In order to make this world a more humane and safer place, we need to realize how interdependent we are and be responsible for one another. We do not need to be religious or spiritual to appreciate this reality and act accordingly.
What would happen if we allow these bumps to be learning experiences? What would happen if teachers asked their students for help, or trusted them to have an active part in thei educational community? There is much talk of the shifts in education; one shift that I believe is happening is that students are becoming efficient inter-learners (and inter-educators). I learn from my Computer Applications students every week. They have gone so far as to say “Ms. Cronk, if you want to understand what we are talking about; check this site out.” Every time they bring me a resource I use it, just as I hope they do with the information I give them. Granted, some of the resources my students share with me are funny, but they still help me understand them on another level.







